If you were considering weight loss surgery a decade ago, gastric bands were the procedure of choice. They resembled the iPhone of the bariatric world in that they were sleek, minimally invasive, and a symbol of rapid and 'simple' weight loss. Fast forward to today, and it's a whole different story. According to the most recent studies, their popularity has fallen, you may be wondering why this sudden fall from grace has occurred so here is a bit of background for you.
Around the early 2000s, gastric bands were hailed as the future of bariatric surgery. You could almost hear the trumpets blare and see confetti rain down as this seemingly magic solution came to the fore. Medical professionals and patients alike were enamored by its 'quick fix' allure. Why? Well, it was a simpler, seemingly less daunting approach to tackling obesity. For those who are not familiar with the procedure, let's briefly take a look at what gastric banding is. Picture this: a silicone band is wrapped around the upper part of your stomach, creating a smaller pouch. Think of it as turning your stomach into an hourglass figure, where food enters the slimmer, upper section first. The result? You feel fuller quicker, thus cutting down on your food intake. No cutting, stapling, or re-routing of your digestive tract. A nip and tuck for your stomach, if you will.
During its heyday, gastric bands were the epitome of weight-loss aspirations. With its lower risk and shorter recovery time, it attracted a wide demographic—from busy execs who couldn’t afford downtime, to older folks for whom more invasive procedures could be risky. It was the poster child of inclusivity in the realm of weight loss surgeries.
But like all things that seem too good to be true—there was more to the story, which we'll delve into later. However, for a good chunk of the early 21st century, the gastric band was the 'it' solution, like the Atkins diet in the 90s or avocado toast for millennials. It was THE buzzword in bariatric circles, and for a while, it seemed like its reign would last.
Why was it the in thing in the 90s?
First of all, let's talk about portion control. Gastric bands act like a natural barrier for your appetite. With a smaller stomach pouch, you feel satiated much quicker. Suddenly, you're saying goodbye to second helpings and reducing portion sizes without a second thought. It’s like your stomach is on a natural portion-control app, minus the annoying notifications.
Next up is the non-invasive allure. Think about it, the idea of having your digestive system re-routed or a portion of your stomach cut out sounds daunting, doesn't it? Gastric bands were the less scary alternative. A simple band placed around the stomach? Sounds like a walk in the park! This drew in people who were apprehensive about going under the knife in a more 'drastic' manner. It's like dipping your toes in the weight-loss surgery pool without having to dive in head first!.
But the cherry on top? Reversibility. If you didn’t fancy your new gastric-accentuated life or if complications arose the band could be adjusted or entirely removed. It gave people the comfort of an "undo" button, a safety net that few other bariatric surgeries offer.
In summary, gastric bands were the triple threat of the bariatric world: immediate portion control, minimally invasive, and reversible. For a time, this made them the hottest ticket in town, like a VIP pass to the weight-loss express. But as you'll see, even VIP passes come with small print!
What are the downsides of the gastric band?
First off, let's tackle the elephant in the room—ineffectiveness over the long term. You see, initially, people who get a gastric band often see promising weight loss, but fast-forward a few years and many find the weight creeping back up. Some studies have even shown that about half of the patients regain some of the weight they lost within five years. You know how your car starts to lose its sheen and efficiency after a few years? Well, the band can act similarly. It can slip out of place, erode into the stomach, or just not be as effective as before.
Now, onto complications. And we're not talking about minor hiccups; we're talking full-blown, call-the-doctor-right-now type of complications. Band erosion, for instance, occurs when the band literally starts sinking into your stomach wall—sounds like something out of a horror movie, right? Then there’s slippage, where the band moves and your stomach pouch becomes bigger or smaller. Imagine walking in ill-fitting shoes; it's uncomfortable and can lead to all sorts of issues and we haven't even touched upon the risk of infection.
But here’s the real kicker—psychological factors. Let's be honest; a band won't cure binge-eating tendencies or sort out the emotional baggage that often accompanies obesity. Let's say, for example, you’re a stress eater. The band may make your stomach smaller, but it won’t make the stresses of your job or family life disappear. If emotional eating is your way of coping, you'll find a way to eat around the band, liquid calories, or even worse, develop new unhealthy habits.
So people soon discovered gastric bands aren't the one-size-fits-all miracle solution they were once thought to be.
What are my options fast forward 2023?
In the fast-evolving world of bariatric surgery, newer alternatives are stealing the spotlight from gastric bands. Among these are Gastric Sleeves, Gastric Bypasses, and let's not forget, the Allurion Balloon.
Starting with Gastric Sleeves, this procedure trims down your stomach to about 15% of its original size, resembling a sleeve. It offers dual benefits: physical food restriction and hormonal changes that curb appetite. Gastric Bypasses, the Jack-of-all-trades in the bariatric world, not only shrink your stomach but reroute your intestines as well. The result? Faster, more enduring weight loss. Now, the Allurion Balloon is like the Tesla of weight-loss methods—innovative and non-surgical. An inflatable balloon is placed in your stomach and filled with saline, creating a feeling of fullness. No scalpels, no stitches, and you're in and out within the day.
But why are these methods gaining preference? According to the American Society for Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery, gastric bypass and sleeve patients can lose up to 60-80% and 50-70% of their excess weight respectively, compared to the 40-60% from gastric bands. Surgeons like Dr. Raul Rosenthal, former president of the society, has been quoted saying that the bypass is "the gold standard" in bariatric surgery. So, if you're exploring bariatric options, don't stop at gastric bands. The stage is brimming with newer, more efficient performers that deserve your attention.
Not Completely Writing off Gastric Bands!
Up until now, it might seem like we’ve been throwing gastric bands under the proverbial bus, haven’t we? But let's put the brakes on for a moment and explore why, for some folks, this old-school method might still be their preference.
Lets talk about situational applicability. Not everyone is a candidate for more invasive surgeries like gastric bypasses or sleeves. Imagine someone in their late 50s with a history of cardiac issues. Going in for an operation that involves rerouting your intestines or removing a chunk of your stomach is like trying to run a marathon with a sprained ankle. Possible? Maybe. Advisable? Not so much. A gastric band, in this case, maybe more of a calculated, safer option. It’s like choosing to read a paperback when you’ve got screen fatigue; it might not be cutting-edge, but it does the job without the drawbacks.
Now, who should actually be thumbing through the gastric band brochure with a serious glint in their eye? If you're someone who's tried all other weight loss measures but is not a candidate for more invasive surgeries due to other health issues, take note. Or perhaps you have a lower BMI, just high enough to warrant surgical intervention but not so high that you need the big guns like a gastric bypass. Gastric bands can be a sort of 'Bariatric Surgery Lite'—lower risks and reversibility make it a less daunting commitment.
And let's not forget those with specific lifestyle needs. Take, for instance, professional athletes who need to lose weight but can’t afford extensive downtime for recovery. A gastric band could serve as a compromise that gets them back in the game quicker. It's like choosing a ready meal when you don't have time for a gourmet dinner; it may not be the first choice, but it serves a specific need.
So, lo and behold, the gastric band isn't the relic we may have painted it to be. For some, it's still a viable option even though it has its limitations and it's far from perfect. Therefore, before you completely write off gastric bands, consider the nuance. They might not be the star of the show anymore, but they're far from ready to take their final bow.
In conclusion
It is clear that the world of weight loss surgery is as diverse as it is dynamic. So, what should be your next move if you are considering weight loss surgery?
Do your own research, write down your medical history, lifestyle, weight loss goals, and any psychological factors like emotional eating that you're grappling with, then book an appointment with a well-researched bariatric surgeon and discuss your options with them. You may also wish to consider getting a second or third opinion. Remember, this is your body, your life, and your future we're talking about. There's no 'one-size-fits-all'; it's about finding what fits your needs, remember—this is not just about losing weight, you are gaining a whole new chapter in your life story so cheers to that!
If you enjoyed this blog, I will encourage you to Join our mailing list to keep up to date with our blogs.
Until next time, live fierce and fabulous!
To find out more about Bariatric Health visit our website
Comments